Huberman Lab
How to Enhance Performance & Learning by Applying a Growth Mindset
Mon Jul 17 2023Description
The episode explores the concept of growth mindset, which involves embracing challenge, distancing identity from challenges, and attaching identity to effort and learning. It discusses the impact of feedback on performance, the influence of mindsets on core beliefs, and the importance of effort-based praise. The episode also delves into the relationship between mindsets and brain activity, the role of stress in performance enhancement, and the practical applications of growth mindset and stress-enhancing mindsets in various contexts.
Insights
Growth mindset involves embracing challenge and optimizing performance
Developing a growth mindset means distancing your identity from challenges and attaching it to effort and learning
Feedback based on identity labels undermines performance
Effort-based praise should be prioritized over intelligence praise in everyday settings
Mindsets shape our attention and responses
Growth mindset forces us to question our narratives and beliefs
Praise for effort improves performance, while intelligence praise can reduce it
Children praised for effort tend to outperform those praised for intelligence
Beliefs about intelligence influence learning success
Shifting from performance narratives to effort-related narratives enhances learning ability
Effort and engagement are crucial for improvement in any domain
Thinking about successes and failures through the lens of effort allows for continuous improvement
Timing of praise doesn't matter, always strive to give genuine effort praise
Effort and attention are the only things we can control
Shifting from fixed mindset to growth mindset is possible
Focusing on effort and engaging more leads to elevated performance
Stress-enhancing mindset allows easier access to growth mindset
Beliefs about stress determine its effects on our physiology
Learning about growth mindset and stress-enhancing mindsets improves self-regard and performance
Engaging in tutorials leads to taking on additional challenges in the future
Chapters
- Introduction to Growth Mindset
- Mindsets and Identity
- Feedback and Core Beliefs
- Praise and Performance
- Misrepresentation and Beliefs
- Effort and Performance
- Timing of Praise and Control
- Brain Activity and Confidence
- Shifting Mindsets and Stress
- Stress and Performance
- Educating on Stress and Mindsets
- Analyzing Errors and Mindset Shifts
- The Learning Process and Mindset Building
- Research Findings and Practical Applications
- Conclusion and Key Takeaways
Introduction to Growth Mindset
00:00 - 06:35
- Growth mindset involves embracing challenge and optimizing performance
- Developing a growth mindset means distancing your identity from challenges
- Praise or feedback that attaches identity to performance can undermine performance
- Growth mindset is about attaching identity and motivation to effort and learning
- Combining growth mindset with a stress-enhancing mindset improves performance
- Neuroplasticity is at the core of growth mindset, allowing the brain to change through deliberate focus on learning
Mindsets and Identity
06:13 - 12:43
- Mindsets organize and encode information, shaping our attention and responses
- Mindsets include narratives attached to our sense of identity
- Growth mindset forces us to question our narratives and beliefs
- Reflect on what you're good at and where those messages came from
- Feedback based on identity labels vs. effort has different effects on performance
Feedback and Core Beliefs
12:19 - 19:11
- Early feedback shapes core beliefs about what is possible in an endeavor
- We can modify core beliefs by changing the feedback we give ourselves
- Praise for intelligence undermines motivation and performance
- Intelligence praise leads to selecting easier problems, while effort praise leads to selecting harder problems
- Praise reinforces behavior patterns, but intelligence praise focuses on being told one is smart rather than engaging in the activity
Praise and Performance
18:50 - 25:49
- Children praised for effort tend to outperform those praised for intelligence
- Be cautious about feedback attached to a child's identity in an endeavor
- Rewarding oneself for effort is the best way to improve performance
- Intelligence praise can reduce performance, while effort praise improves performance
- Effort praise should be prioritized over intelligence praise in everyday settings
Misrepresentation and Beliefs
25:25 - 31:56
- Intelligence praise can lead to misrepresentation of performance
- Kids who receive intelligence praise are more likely to lie about their performance
- Effort praise does not lead to misrepresentation of performance
- Beliefs about intelligence influence learning success
- Shifting from performance narratives to effort-related narratives enhances learning ability
Effort and Performance
31:35 - 38:14
- Effort and engagement are crucial for improvement in any domain
- Performance labels can lead to a sense of identity, which can be detrimental when performance diminishes
- Thinking about successes and failures through the lens of effort allows for continuous improvement
- Labels of intelligence or identity undermine performance
- Effort-based praise before a challenge improves performance
Timing of Praise and Control
37:49 - 44:33
- Effort praise after performance increases future effort
- Identity praise before performance decreases subsequent performance
- Timing of praise doesn't matter, always strive to give genuine effort praise
- Effort and attention are the only things we can control
- Beliefs about intelligence influence learning success
Brain Activity and Confidence
44:12 - 50:52
- Brain activity can be recorded to measure accuracy and confidence
- Fixed mindset individuals show larger error signals in emotional brain areas
- Growth mindset individuals focus on cognitive appraisal of errors
- Shifting from fixed mindset to growth mindset is possible
- Focusing on effort and engaging more leads to elevated performance
Shifting Mindsets and Stress
50:28 - 57:20
- Shifting from fixed mindset to growth mindset is important
- Devoting attentional resources to understanding errors builds up growth mindset
- Stress-enhancing mindset allows easier access to growth mindset
- Thinking about stress impacts how we react to it
- Beliefs about stress determine its effects on our physiology
Stress and Performance
56:53 - 1:03:55
- Learning that stress can enhance performance significantly without training or practice
- Stress response depends on cognitive appraisal, not inherently good or bad
- Stress mobilizes resources for adaptive challenges
- Learning that stress enhances performance allows adjustment of stress response in real time
- Embracing a stress-enhancing mindset leads to improved performance under stress
Educating on Stress and Mindsets
1:03:34 - 1:10:01
- Educating oneself on how stress can enhance performance buffers against anticipatory stress
- Learning about mindsets offsets the stress response and improves performance
- Learning about growth mindset and stress-enhancing mindsets shifts physiology and enhances performance
- Brief interventions have significant impact on shifting mindset and improving performance
- Tools for building mindsets include adopting them as teachers and students, focusing on verbs when giving feedback, and analyzing errors analytically
Analyzing Errors and Mindset Shifts
1:09:40 - 1:16:36
- Focus on analyzing verbs that led to errors, rather than getting caught up in emotions
- Allow time to process emotional experience before engaging in error analysis
- Seek help from others to gain understanding of why performance was not as desired
- Teachers and students embracing mindsets are most effective for learning
- Write a letter explaining mindsets if no teacher or mentor is available
- Learning involves stress and strain that triggers the learning process
The Learning Process and Mindset Building
1:16:31 - 1:23:44
- The mind is not like a muscle; learning involves stress and strain for growth
- Experiencing strain and agitation is part of the learning process itself
- Stress, frustration, and difficulty maintaining focus create conditions for learning
- Growth mindset and stress-enhancing mindset improve performance synergistically
- Building up mindsets takes time and belief in their power to have real effects
Research Findings and Practical Applications
1:23:23 - 1:30:27
- Learning about growth mindset and stress-enhancing mindsets improves self-regard and performance
- Engaging in tutorials leads to taking on additional challenges in the future
- Tools for building mindsets include adopting them as teachers and students, focusing on verbs when giving feedback, and analyzing errors analytically
Conclusion and Key Takeaways
1:30:08 - 1:36:49
- Focus on analyzing verbs that led to errors, rather than getting caught up in emotions
- Seek help from others to gain understanding of why performance was not as desired
- Teachers and students embracing mindsets are most effective for learning
- The mind is not like a muscle; learning involves stress and strain for growth